迈克·布罗迪的画作《失败》中描绘的一位年轻男孩的肖像

书评 迈克·布罗迪——失败

© 迈克·布罗迪

“Failing”: After a ten-year hiatus, Mike Brodie returns with his highly anticipated third monograph.


─── by Josh Bright, 3 月 19, 2025

Few photographers today are as intriguing as Mike Brodie, also known as “The Polaroid Kid.” His name carries an almost mythical resonance, shaped by the impact of his powerful early work and his subsequent, abrupt departure from the photography world.

Photo of apples and books on a car seat by Mike Brodie


His debut monograph, A Period of Juvenile Prosperity, was released in 2013 to widespread acclaim. Beginning in 2004, when Brodie was in his late teens, he spent four years freight-hopping across America, documenting fellow rail riders and drifters in a reckless, wildfire pursuit of adventure and freedom, a tradition echoed in the words of Steinbeck, Kerouac, London, and Woody Guthrie, among many others

Photo of a chimney and smoke by Mike Brodie


It was followed by Dirt and Bone, a collection of his earliest images, taken on a Polaroid camera before he acquired the Nikon F3, which he used for his debut monograph — and thenceforth.

The desire for adventure, for the open road — or the open rail, as it were — feels deeply ingrained in the American psyche, fueling some of the most iconic imagery in contemporary photography, from Robert Frank’s seminal work to the color pioneers like Stephen Shore and 乔尔·斯特恩菲尔德. Brodie may belong to this tradition, yet his style remains uniquely his own. His lack of formal training and his closeness with the people he photographs engender raw, intimate, and deeply personal images, fleeting, unguarded moments captured by a participant rather than an outsider looking in.

Photo of hands holding a baseball in a red cloth by Mike Brodie
Photo of a statue of an angel behind bars by Mike Brodie
Photo of a bathtub with red paint in it by Mike Brodie


In that way, he has more in common with Nan Goldin than the luminaries, as mentioned earlier. Goldin entered the photography world with a style wholly her own, free from the shackles of a formal photography education, unflinchingly personal and compelling. Likewise Brodie. As Danny Lyon put it in his review of A Period of Juvenile Prosperity 为了 Aperture, “he leapt into the life of picture-making as if he was the first to do it.”

Portrait of a woman holding a small crucifix by Mike Brodie


A decade has passed since Brodie’s second book, a decade in which his legend has only grown in his absence. He settled in Nashville, worked as a diesel mechanic, and eventually moved across the country for love. He married, bought land along the dusty Winnemucca road Johnny Cash sang about in “I’ve Been Everywhere,” started a business, built a house, and put down roots. When that life unraveled, the open road called him back. Through it all, his camera remained by his side. Failing is the artistic culmination of those ten years.

Photo of cars on a highway bridge by Mike Brodie
Photo of personal items in plastic box by Mike Brodie
Brodie-FAILING-12


A Period of Juvenile Prosperity was a masterpiece in youthful abandon, a raw yet beautiful encapsulation of the kind of freedom you only feel when you have nothing to lose. Even in its grittier moments, there was an undeniable sense of hope, of optimism, of running full speed into the unknown without a second thought. The golden light, the expansive landscapes; it all felt untethered. Weightless.

Failing, however, is something else. Growing older doesn’t feel gradual; it sneaks up on you. One day, you wake up and realize the dreams you had as a kid didn’t quite pan out. The beautiful delusion of youth fades, replaced by something harder to swallow. These images feel more confined, more fragmented, perhaps a reflection of that reality.

迈克·布罗迪的画作《失败》中描绘的一位年轻男孩的肖像


The people depicted — hitchhikers, drifters, kindred spirits caught in-between — faces marked by exhaustion, defiance, or something harder to define. Maybe they were once, like him, youthful travelers, crossing the vast American plains on rust-cloaked train cars, chasing an untamed dream of freedom, now weathered by time and circumstance. Addiction and pain linger alongside fleeting moments of beauty and joy. Symbols emerge in discarded objects and quiet gestures. Animals, both alive and dead. Brodie’s world is raw and unvarnished. Sometimes tender. Sometimes brutal. But always deeply felt.

The openness of his debut has given way to something more introspective. Yet still, the road remains almost ever-present. Often seen through dust-cloaked windows. A constant pull. Magnetic. Impossible to ignore.

Photo by Mike Brodie, from his book Failing


Brodie’s eye remains as sharp as ever, capturing that intangible poetry of everyday life on the margins. Failing is different to his earlier work, but it’s still unequivocally him. And though it might not make the impact of his debut, in some ways, it’s even more powerful.

“Maybe I’m walking down the highway all day, thinking, what am I doing with my life? And then, all of a sudden, out of nowhere, some magical thing happens. And I take ten photos and it reinvigorates the feeling. And I realize, I am on the right path. This is okay.”


所有图片版权所有 Mike Brodie

Failing is published by Twin Palms and is available via their 网站。.

隐私概览
独立摄影师

本网站使用 Cookie,以便为您提供最佳用户体验。Cookie 信息存储在您的浏览器中,其功能包括在您再次访问本网站时识别您的身份,以及帮助我们的团队了解您最感兴趣和最有用的网站版块。.

绝对必要的 Cookie

必须始终启用“绝对必要的 Cookie”,以便我们保存您的 Cookie 设置偏好。.

分析

本网站使用 Google Analytics 收集匿名信息,例如网站访问者数量和最受欢迎的页面。.

启用此 Cookie 有助于我们改进网站。.